Best Raven's Skill Player to Ever Suit Up

[HotInHere]

Like I said above, I don't see the point in mentioning a player as a great for the Ravens when the stats they put up while playing for us where mediocre. Obviously Sharpe is a all time great, but he did nothing spectacular stat wise here.

Read the thread title.

I didn't make the rules. Baldy wasn't talking about how they performed as Ravens. He asked for greatest skill players to suit up for at least one game.

Another guy who deserves mention on that basis is Air McNair.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HbgPARavenfan]

I'll go with Priest Holmes. He was the AFC's version of Marshall Faulk. If he would've had a healthier career, he would be in the HOF right now.

Holmes wasnt special here compared to what he did in KC.


I'd go with Rice. He was a special player for multiple years.

I think people pushing Boldin are overvaluing him based on sentimental feelings.

[Goode05]

Read the thread title.

I didn't make the rules. Baldy wasn't talking about how they performed as Ravens. He asked for greatest skill players to suit up for at least one game.

Another guy who deserves mention on that basis is Air McNair.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Qbs were excluded


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Bhcforlife]

Holmes wasnt special here compared to what he did in KC.


I'd go with Rice. He was a special player for multiple years.

I think people pushing Boldin are overvaluing him based on sentimental feelings.

I don't think Boldin compares either as a "Raven guy", where Rice and Lewis would both rank higher, or "literal guy" where Sr. and Sharpe would both be higher.

[Goode05]

Sharp,SSSr,
Jamal Lewis , Ray Rice
Boldin


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[whosyourdaddy1213]

I'll add T.J. Houshmandzadeh to the pot

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G891A using Tapatalk

[HotInHere]

Qbs were excluded


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

My bad, thanks.

So you've got one guy in the HoF (Sharpe,) and two that are probably headed there eventually (SSSr and Boldin.)

Then you have your Hall of Almost guys (Mason, Jamal, Priest.) If they had done a little more, or a little longer, they would be in the HoF consideration.

Then you have your guys who were real good for awhile at some point in their careers (Heap, Rice, Clark.)

Then you have Torrey and Housh, but I'm not sure why either would be mentioned in the same breath with the others. Might as well list Qadry Ismail.

And then you have Breshad Perriman.

[QuothDaRaven]

Derrick Mason had a pretty solid career overall also, including his stint as a Raven.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[WrongBaldy]

No doubt he was awesome, but I just don't get putting guys on this list that didn't perform in the conversation that we are talking about while wearing our uniform.

i didnt say his performance as a ravens - best offensive player to ever play for us

[WrongBaldy]

Shannon Sharpe retired as probably the greatest TE of all time. Doesn't he at least deserve a mention in this thread? Certainly over Heap or Clark.

oh man sharpe belongs up there too

[WrongBaldy]

My bad, thanks.

So you've got one guy in the HoF (Sharpe,) and two that are probably headed there eventually (SSSr and Boldin.)

Then you have your Hall of Almost guys (Mason, Jamal, Priest.) If they had done a little more, or a little longer, they would be in the HoF consideration.

Then you have your guys who were real good for awhile at some point in their careers (Heap, Rice, Clark.)

Then you have Torrey and Housh, but I'm not sure why either would be mentioned in the same breath with the others. Might as well list Qadry Ismail.

And then you have Breshad Perriman.

thats a pretty good summary.

[QuothDaRaven]

Technically Devin Hester was a Raven too :) Greatest return man of all time.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk