Results 25 to 36 of 47
-
Re: Lawful Police Order.....obey or don't. You choose.
Maybe theres more posts out there that clear some of that up that i didnt see. how does the totals factor into that and prove your point? theres double the whites shot by cops as blacks every year". Ok. If were just breaking it out by race, there shouldnt be a discrepancy (at least that large) outside the population percentage. we may agree on the real underlying issue here, but ill disagree with how youre linking those totals to it, which were divided by race and not crime.
Heres a chart of crime, which I think is a better representation/correlation. When I said there are other factors, this social/economic issue of urban areas and that crime rate is what i was referring to, which NC pointed out is the better correlation and I agree.
https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s...decoverviewpdf
to me, this lines up with those numbers better. Whites commit 2x as many crimes as blacks in most cases. so when considering those that commit crimes, youre about equal to get shot doing so, regardless of race.
To my latter point as to why somebody, particularly in the black community, may have the perspective that theres something going on (that isnt) based off that, is because youre a lot more likely to come to that feeling when looking at those effected by population. using the 3/1000 vs 9/1000. theres going to be 3x as many friends/family effected and seeing/having first hand experience of those that are shot by police. Its a ripple effect. Its ignoring the impact of such, and the human element within those communities.
Unjust shootings are part of whats getting mixed up here and happen with all races, and are something I do agree with happens more than it should. There is no taking back deadly force but thats completely subjective on a case by case scenario. Are those happening more or less in the black community? I have no idea, but that above ripple effect is going to be similar. I know Ive seen videos of white suspects shot in questionable terms as well as black or hispanic or whatever. I think thats a different issue, a need for better police recruitment and training whcih ive talked about here before.
as far as any of this proving systemic racism doesnt exist? i dont really see them as that related. I think one is the result of enforcing laws, whether or not those laws are racist in their conception, is outside enforcing them once made. Id sooner say those pointing to cop shootings as a sign of systemic are just as wrong as those arguing those numbers prove there isnt.Last edited by JAB1985; 08-15-2018 at 01:56 PM.
-JAB
-
-
08-15-2018, 02:01 PM #27
-
08-15-2018, 02:18 PM #28
-
Re: Lawful Police Order.....obey or don't. You choose.
Thats a good observation and certainly true in the context that they dont account for latinos separately based on these numbers. assuming law enforcement is lumping all Latinos as white im not sure is accurate. Id guess that depends more on skin tone than just all latinos are considered white, or at least varies to some degree nationally on how thats considered. maybe case by case. I could see one being more influenced than the other, but both are probably higher than reality based off that.
These numbers certainly still have their issues. Most states use a black, white, or other basis for distinguishing race during arrests, despite Latinos accounting for more than blacks currently within the population. I would think if we had harder data for them, wed see a similar issue, as they make up a larger percentage of high population/low education areas similar to blacks.-JAB
-
08-15-2018, 02:56 PM #30
-
08-15-2018, 03:42 PM #31
-
08-15-2018, 04:42 PM #32Veteran Poster
- Join Date
- Oct 2015
- Posts
- 3,701
Re: Lawful Police Order.....obey or don't. You choose.
-
08-15-2018, 04:50 PM #33
-
-
-
Bookmarks