Results 25 to 32 of 32
Thread: Bradley Manning Verdict
-
08-22-2013, 10:13 AM #25Legendary RSR Poster
- Join Date
- Aug 2007
- Location
- Houston, TX Y'all
- Posts
- 34,414
Re: Bradley Manning Verdict
Yes. All the way up to and including the President.
There's a process in place if you feel an order is immoral. Soldiers, Sailors, Marines and Airmen are sworn to protect Democracy, not practice it.
Id also add that when Manning with through MEPS, he was told all of this dozens of times prior to him signing his contract.
-
08-22-2013, 10:25 AM #26
Re: Bradley Manning Verdict
Totally understand that. But if Manning at least tried to go through official channels first. If he tried to do it the right way and the military/government cock blocked every which way...and he still felt compelled enough to share this information with the American public and then release it the way he did...I would have alot more respect for and possibly laud Manning.
As it stands all he did was walk into the SCIF he worked, copy random files from SIPRNET and release it to Wikileaks. I was still active duty at the time, and my coworkers and I (all holding TS clearances and worked in SCIFs) felt he was a young kid looking for his 15 minutes and didn't think through the ramifications of his actions.
I take my clearance very seriously. The government has put in me a large trust that I will work with classified information and not reveal it. In 12+ plus years working in a classified environment I have yet to come across information that I feel the general public needs to be aware of.Master of 'Gifs for dummies'
"The world called for wetwork, and we answered. No greater good. No just cause." - Kazuhira Miller
-
-
08-22-2013, 11:04 AM #28Veteran Poster
- Join Date
- Aug 2012
- Posts
- 4,464
Re: Bradley Manning Verdict
Dade. Totally understand. And while I don't work with TOP Secret info, I do deal with sensitive info and take that responsibility seriously, as well.
Of all the whistleblowers that have come to light over the last few years, I am most uncomfortable with the way Manning disclosed the information.
-
08-22-2013, 12:15 PM #29Veteran Poster
- Join Date
- Oct 2011
- Posts
- 4,553
Re: Bradley Manning Verdict
It isn't just the way he revealed the information, imo. It is that virtually none of it even deserved to be released at all. He wasn't "blowing the whistle" on anything substantial; he was simply exposing secrets.
I don't see anything that is clearly illegal or unconstitutional. Spying on foreigners, no. Leaning on allies, no. Supporting dubious regimes while holding your nose, no. Collateral damage in wars, no. "Hints of corruption and bribes" regarding Boeing, maybe, but "hints" doesn't sound like proof, nor does that miniscule issue warrant dumping as many damaging secrets as possible to Assange.
You also have to realize that Manning almost assuredly has gotten innocent, honorable people killed by releasing these files. These files exposed many foreigners who were secretly helping the US against their own ruthless countrymen while living in a very hostile environment. His buddy, Assange, when asked about Afghan informants being killed after being exposed by the release of the classified information: "They're informants... if they get killed, they deserve it." Despicable. Assange is rooting for the Taliban, make no mistake about it. And Manning naively hitched his wagon to this clown.
I see zero honor in Manning's actions. And I would feel the same way if he raised internal stinks, was rebuffed, resigned his commission, and released the files. Disapproving of foreign policy is not a just cause to expose classified information, especially if innocent people are going to die as a result of the release. The whistleblower hurdle is massively higher, imo, and it wasn't close to being met with 98% of what was released.Last edited by Haloti92; 08-22-2013 at 12:25 PM.
-
-
08-22-2013, 05:02 PM #31
-
Re: Bradley Manning Verdict
First, just a very partial list from "Cablegate" (keep in mind, this does not include many other bombshells that caused a stir in smaller nations abroad):
-Details on Vatican hiding big sex abuse cases in Ireland.
And people knew it before then but nobody ever spoke up and demanded answers.
Bookmarks