I agree Beau, it is very hard, the 2 Super Bowls debate is good, but Joe is still young. I still think both are great QB's.
Printable View
I agree Beau, it is very hard, the 2 Super Bowls debate is good, but Joe is still young. I still think both are great QB's.
drocks-
I think you've hit the nail on the head - both QBs are pretty damn good! Whether one is "better" than the other sounds to me like a school yard debate! ;)
I've always thought that Eli was vastly over-rated. Defense won the giants 2 super bowls.Quote:
Originally Posted by JAB1985
They're both clutch QBs. Maybe not the best stats around, but when the season is on the line I can't think of any QBs I'd take over them. Flacco gets the nod since he plays for us though.
Again, what is Canty going to say here? There's two responses:
1. He's better than Eli
2. Eli and Joe are both great QBs
The second one is a bit of a cop out, the 1st one is the route to go if you want to endear yourselves to your new fans.
I don't read this as any deep insight. I'm sure Boldin is going to say Kaepernick is a more dynamic QB than Joe and be nothing but complimentary of him over Flacco. And I wouldn't expect anything less
He had game winning touchdown drives in both of them.Quote:
Originally Posted by steelerhater
This seems to me just to be new player loving his team, however it was interesting as Canty being a defensive player that he threw in the "tape don't lie" quote.
Eli and Joe are similar QB's in some ways, a bit different in others. Their stats are similar, but Eli has had some really bad years thrown in there too.
Physically, Joe is more gifted in most every way.
Both are pretty much the definition of clutch.
He didn't have to diss anyone. Just say how happy he is to be here to get another shot at a ring. Boldin hasn't dissed the Ravens saying JIm is a better coach than John. He knows Ozzie did him a favor by not trading to say, um, Buffalo or
Miami.
Maybe Canty's pissed for being let go cause he was a cap casualty.
Whatever, I'm glad we have him. Who do they double team - Canty? Ngata? McPhee?
Suggs? Upshaw? Brown? Then we still have Spears, Jones and Brandon.
Someone is always going to get thru.
Air Flacco the voice of reason.
It is ridiculous to talk about 1 player in a team sport.
With the tape dont lie quote he could have a point. I mean last year Flacco was money
Joe was clutch even in NE a year ago when Evans dropped the ball in the end zone. Experts around the country were impressed at Joe under pressure.
Joe dropped it right in his lap. It wasn't JOe's fault he didn't secure the ball.
Same in Pissburgh a couple of years ago when Boldin dropped the ball on the goal line.
TJ dropped another one but in each case Joe was money in the clutch and did his
job. Those drops kept Joe from yet another SB.
Finally this year no one choked on him but in past years he didn't have the receivers
Eli had like Cruz and Nicks et al. He had Mason who kept disappearing in the POs
like in Piss and Indy and Evans and TJ choking on him but Joe was every bit as good
as Eli while losing.
And of course, Boldin made up for PIss this year in NO.