Results 13 to 24 of 26
Thread: Ellerbe played at 266
-
-
10-05-2012, 11:10 AM #14Hall Of Fame Poster
- Join Date
- Dec 2010
- Posts
- 8,743
-
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
Upshaw has a much bigger frame than Ellerbe. Ellerbe is narrower though the shoulders, hips and has much smaller legs. Upshaw is a DE/LB hybrid.
Totally different body types. Ellerbe has a small frame, his calling card was supposed to be quickness coming out of college. I think, could be wrong that he was in the 230lb range in college.
Upshaw could add 10 lbs easy and be a DE. Upshaw is basically a JJ.
-
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
Thompson, our FS, is going to fill in for Ellerbe at LB or do you mean well play more nickel and dime utilizing Thompson as opposed to ANY ILB? Thompsons future is at FS, on this team, maybe as soon as next year.
honestly i think Ellerbe is back at this point. I dont think hes going to cost that much to retain and well have BA and Lewis another year older or retired. Well most likely draft one but that doesnt mean we wont need to retain the little depth we have as well. we carry 4 currently, and id assume well carry the same moving forward.-JAB
-
10-05-2012, 01:15 PM #17
-
10-05-2012, 01:31 PM #18
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
I mean "fill in", but only as an option. So if for any reason the need for a coverage LB becomes greater than the need for an FS, then Thompson could possibly go LB. He's an athletic thumper with decent range, but lacks instincts. Of course, he could be our 2013 SS, if Pollard tests the market.
Ed's health, desire to continue to play, desire to continue to play here, Thompson's growth, free agency, the draft, etc., are all factors. That's why I admitted to thinking way too far ahead. Too many unknowns...
-
10-05-2012, 04:19 PM #19Veteran Poster
- Join Date
- Dec 2006
- Posts
- 3,161
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
JJ came in to the league as a DT and slimmed down to play OLB/DE. I thought/think it is funny when guys on here argued about Upshaw coming in to camp and try to play at 270lbs and that he should be closer to 265lbs. Really??? 5 WHOLE pounds??? Guys who argue that must weigh 145lbs and think that 5lbs is a big deal. Hell, I'm anywhere from 245-255 on any given day and I can gain or lose 5lbs if i take a good shit, and guys on here think Upshaw being 270 and not 265 is a big deal....hilarious.
-
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
266 is way too big for today's NFL.
Frankly, 270 is probably too big for OLB too...Woodley played at that size last year and his coaches called him out for being fat and out of shape.
-
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
They called him out coming into training camp at 290, not at his playing weight of 270. He plays at 270 and has for the last 3 years.
265 is not too big depending on your role.
Suggs plays at 265 and has forever, except that one year where he was out of shape.
This really is much ado about nothing.Follow me on Twitter! https://twitter.com/#!/thenflanalyst
-
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
The dude was fat last year. Everyone could see he had a bubble butt, he was slow and undefined. 265 may be fine for certain players with certain body types but it wasn't fine for Ellerbe. It showed in his play.
He's clearly slimmed down and is playing faster and smarter.
-
Re: Ellerbe played at 266
265 is ok for a 3-4 OLB...not ILB
-
I disagree. It really depends on the player. Brian Cushing is like 260ish. Donta Hightower is 260+. Now, those two guys are 6'4"/6'3", so that makes a difference.
Ellerbe at 260+ is for too heavy IMO because the guy is barely 6'1". 235-245 should be about right for him. When he was at Georgia he was around 230.
Sent from my DROID X2 using Forum RunnerDisclaimer: The content posted is of my own opinion.
Bookmarks