Results 1 to 12 of 47
-
10-16-2006, 12:41 AM #1
Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
McNair:
@TB... 17/27... 181 yds... 63%... 35 long...1 TD ... 0 INT... 94.8 rating
OAK... 16/33... 143 yds... 48.5%... 30 long...1 TD ...1 INT... 58.0 rating
@CLE... 23/41... 264 yds... 56.1%... 38 long...1 TD ...1 INT... 83.8 rating
SD... 17/30... 158 yds... 56.7%... 29 long... 2 TD... 2INT... 65.7 rating
@DEN... 20/34... 165 yds...58.8%... 26 long... 0 TD... 3 INT... 34.6 rating
CAR... 2/4... 4 yds... 50%... 4 long... 0 TD... 1 INT... 16.7 rating
Boller:
CAR... 17/31... 226 yds... 54.8%... 62 long... 3 TD... 1 INT... 97.0 rating
Is there a trend, perhaps?
:T2:
-
10-16-2006, 04:31 AM #2
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
Yeah.
No matter who the QB is we're going to put up the exact same stats passing.
Taking away the one really long lucky TD to Clayton, Boller had an average Ravens day passing.
What I did like to see was him actually moving the ball.
Of the three possessions McNair started, we went punt, INT, punt. Three three-and-outs.
Of the eight Boller started we had four three-and-outs, but one was a fumble and another resulted in a TD."A moron, a rapist, and a Pittsburgh Steeler walk into a bar. He sits down and says, “Hi I’m Ben may I have a drink please?”
ProFootballMock
-
10-16-2006, 09:57 AM #3
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
[QUOTE=darb72;13810]
Taking away the one really long lucky TD to Clayton, Boller had an average Ravens day passing.
What I did like to see was him actually moving the ball.QUOTE]
-
10-16-2006, 10:20 AM #4
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
So basically Boller's first game was about as good as McNair's this year. The difference is we lost the game.
-
10-16-2006, 11:10 AM #5Regular 1st Stringer
- Join Date
- Sep 2006
- Location
- In your head
- Posts
- 443
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
-
10-16-2006, 12:10 PM #6
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
Your think the OL is bad well here is your proof.
-
10-17-2006, 11:44 PM #7
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
Your think the OL is bad well here is your proof.
Forced Grbac into retirement.
Boller injured
Wright injured
Boller injured
McNair injured
But I'm betting we're going to hear how our OL is as good as some other team in our division. Well, you'll hear it. I won't have to read it. ;)
-
10-17-2006, 11:53 PM #8
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
Oh yeah, if Boller can manage to get two poorly throw balls tipped
If you would be reasonable in your analysis you might not get people pounding your reputation.
-
10-18-2006, 12:27 AM #9
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
get a more accurate picture you need to look at Boller's career stats and McNair's. That is a more representative sample.
Not that I have to, but I will concede that Mcnair used to be a better than average QB for much of his career. Certainly in 1999, when the Titans went to the SB, and in 2000 and 2001, when there were some epic games against the Ravens and the Titans were serious contenders. And in 2003 he shared the MVP award with Peyton Manning. But that was then and this is now. His performance in those years has no bearing on how mediocre he has become. It was obvious to me last season when we played against him that Father Time and multiple injuries had taken their toll. But the degradation since then has accelerated. There is absolutely no relevance between the McNair of 1999 and 2006. Nor is there any relevance to comparing Boller's rookie stats.
What is relevant is how the two compare now: 97 vs. 16.7.
:T2:
-
10-18-2006, 01:04 AM #10
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
T,
You stick to your guns, and I admire that...but I am going to enjoy watching you eat your words over this McNair noodle-arm non-sense. Remember that first drive of the Giants pre-season game? Mac can make the throws.
-
10-18-2006, 10:37 AM #11
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
Remember that first drive of the Giants pre-season game? Mac can make the throws.
-
10-18-2006, 10:58 AM #12
Re: Stat comparison updated, 2006 QBs only
You stick to your guns, and I admire that...but I am going to enjoy watching you eat your words over this McNair noodle-arm non-sense.
As to the "noodle-arm non-sense", it's obviously a subjective call. I doubt there are speed guns on QBs measuring their output. However, I believe that you'd find that many, probably most, fans and media covering the Ravens have come to this realization - like it or not. Try Google search "McNair arm strength" and enjoy reading!
:T2:
Bookmarks