Supreme Court decision on O'BUMMER CARE TODAY????

[NCRAVEN]

If Roberts writes the opinion and Ginsburg writes the dissent. Ginsburg won't be writing the dissent saying it should be shot down... never happen.

[HoustonRaven]

Neither side is going to be happy with this one, IMO.

Both sides will spin it as a win, but in the end it's going to create more problems than it solves.

Unless it's struck down completely (highly doubtful, IMO), this won't be the end of it.

[NCRAVEN]

Neither side is going to be happy with this one, IMO.

Both sides will spin it as a win, but in the end it's going to create more problems than it solves.

Unless it's struck down completely (highly doubtful, IMO), this won't be the end of it.

Yup, just going to be more lawsuits...

[AirFlacco]

Exactly, HR. This ain't won't be over. Former Atty Gen under
Reagan, Mease was just on and said if Romney wins it will be
repealed.

NC - I meant Ginsburgh will write the dissenting opinion to uphold
it.

Roberts could even punt and tell them to
shelve it and they will vote on it later. By then there will be a
new court with at least 1 maybe 2 conservative judges retiring.
If OBY is re-elected he can put in a liberal court.

[AirFlacco]

Yup, just going to be more lawsuits...

There is another law suit in the appeals court right now brought on
by the independent hospitals. this case was brought on by the
states filed by Florida mins after the bill was signed.

They just took the bench.

[NCRAVEN]

Exactly, HR. This ain't won't be over. Former Atty Gen under
Reagan, Mease was just on and said if Romney wins it will be
repealed.

NC - I meant Ginsburgh will write the dissenting opinion to uphold
it.

Roberts could even punt and tell them to
shelve it and they will vote on it later. By then there will be a
new court with at least 1 maybe 2 conservative judges retiring.
If OBY is re-elected he can put in a liberal court.

Maybe I read it wrong but it looked like you meant Roberts is writing the majority to uphold the whole law.... no biggie.

[AirFlacco]

I quoted his law professor as saying that he will uphold the law.

The general feeling is he's writing the majority to strike down the
mandate.

[AirFlacco]

They just said if the mandate is thrown out and the rest stands, the insurance industry will go bankrupt. This is what we've been saying since the beginning. This is what OBY wants like destroying the
coal and oil industries.

If he's re-elected he will make the gov't the sole provider of health
care ala Gov't Motors.

[AirFlacco]

Roberts is reading the decision now.


MANDATE THROWN OUT.


MANDATE THROWN OUT

MANDATE THROWN OUT

[AirFlacco]

Now we're getting severability.

That means the rest of it. will it be upheld.


There are 4 points of severability.

[NCRAVEN]

Told ya.

[NCRAVEN]

I'm hearing the mandate is a tax and is upheld.