If David Carr Is Cut, Would You Sign Him?

[PurpleRulz]

I sure would and then trade Boller for whatever I could get. Carr could leanr under McNair for one season before taking over. Also, I am not impressed with any of the QBs that will be available (within our reach) over the next two drafts. Of course Brady "Overrated" Quinn and Russell will be out of our range, and in 2008 Colt Brennan and Brohm may both be the top two QBs taken and top ten picks. We won't be within reach of those picks seeing as we will probably be picking in the late first round again in 2008.

David Carr would make a lot of sense. Of course, I have no idea what kind of cap space we currently have, but cap space can be made. Carr needs a change of scenery and could blossom here in Baltimore.

[section553]

He has been cut along with Dominick Davis.

[Tspot-D-Ravenator]

This thread chaps my BUTT..... Freaggin' Boller bashers

[PurpleRulz]

This thread chaps my BUTT..... Freaggin' Boller bashers

Honestly, I don't want to know anything that has to do with yours or any other man's BUTT. I also don't want to know about you "freakin Boller bashers," either.

[ClericBlackDave]

Would I sign Carr? You damn right i would .

I would think that if we had the money to sign Carr, we would have had the money to keep Mulitalo.


Or, to keep Pashos.


Jeeeze, you guys are freaking retards. You don't invest more money into a position that you're set at at this point.


Beyond retarded. Honestly, QB discussions during this offseason for Ravens fans are retarded.


The only discussion we should be having is how did McNair suck so thoroughly at home for our one playoff game? And why can't he throw the deep out? Or any deep route that isn't on a scramble drill?

[crazyraven]

This thread chaps my BUTT

What chaps my ass is that many people spent time and money watching the ravens play Boller, in hindsight we would have been better off playing a sleestack from the Land of the Lost, those things are more mobile and probably scare an opposing offense just a tiny bit more.

Would I sign Carr? You damn right i would .

[Greg]

What I am trying to figure out is why you all are still having these debates.

[jonboy79]

Um, maybe because NFL QB is the most important position in all of sports. If you don't think so, maybe you should pay attention to what the winningest NFL coach of all time has publicly stated. He coached Unitas, Griese, and Marino so he ought to know what he is talking about. He also said that is currently the biggest problem with the Miami Dolphins in that they can't seem to get the QB they need. (A pre-emptive strike before you come back with your usual ridicule of my take on this). BTW, we all saw first hand what a QB can do for a team. T

he Ravens went from no threat to make the playoffs under Boller to a 13-3 team under McNair with little changes to the team otherwise. I have been espousing ever since they have been trying to win with the woefully inadequate Boller at the position, that the Ravens needed a major upgrade. Guess what, I was spot on! Boller to me is like a cancer to this team. The sooner they can eliminate him alltogether the better. Right now he is merely in remission as the backup.

ok, I'll bite. First off, Miami doesn't have a QB with a winning record in the last 3 years , Baltimore has two. The Ravens weent from PERENNIAL playoff contender to SB favorites with the cahgne at QB. With Schaub traded Boller is probably THE BEST backup QB in all of football. Schaub will embarrass himself in HOU, HUard will show why he was a career back-up, as will Garcia. David Garrard already exposed himself inadequate last year. So here is my sum total. Not only is Boller among the top couple back-ups, there are at least a handful of teams that have NO QB's markedly better then him. Give it up, we are not going to have 2 probowl QB's onone team.

[ExiledRaven]

well, I think Garcia could be great, but you have to run the west coast. No west coast, no garcia. He's a system guy.

you may be right about boller being one of the best backups in the NFL this year though we're all hoping Mac9 stays healthy and that doesn't get put to the test.

[jonboy79]

I would take Garcia, Culpepper, Garrard or Leftwich (whomever is the backup) Brunell, Plummer, Collins, Griese, Brad Johnson, Frerotte, and even Chris Simms over Boller as a backup. So how you can say he is among the top couple backups I have no clue. He and Anthony Wright would be bottom feeders in my estimation. They both are among the worst in the league. Sorry, but Boller as a backup isn't any better than Boller as a starter who sucked. He's still playing the same damn position just fortunately for us Ravens fans not nearly as often.

Well, Culpepper will be starting, Plummer is retired and I would take Boller over everyone else on your list, including Garcia who will be starting. That's how. Gimme another list maybe I'll pick another one or two. Funnily enough I think Quinn Gray maybe the best QB on JAX's roster.

[hurting]

Boller isn't even the best backup the Ravens have had on their roster. Dilfer is that guy by a wide margin. Boller, Banks, Blake, Wright, you could put them all in a bag and shake any of them out and there would be no discernable difference in their QB play.

"Mr. Ritter, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. May God have mercy on your soul."

[Greg]

Um, maybe because NFL QB is the most important position in all of sports. If you don't think so, maybe you should pay attention to what the winningest NFL coach of all time has publicly stated.

Blah, blah, blah.

I don't know who the fuck you think you are in comparison to the other posters but I understand the game of football better than you. Hell, I EVEN WATCH THE GAMES!

My comment was in regard to the complete waste of time people on both sides of the argument spend trying to convince the other they are right.