I think you guys are selling McNair short.
Before last Monday against Philly, I myself had the same doubt about his arm.
He was throwing lasers against Philly. Did you notice how he put the ball right between 2 Defenders when he threw that pass to Derrick Mason, that was zip. The same thing with his TD to Quinn Sypnewski, that ball had quite a bit of zip on it.
I have never really seen McNair put much zip on his deep ball, he may have had it when he was much younger, but he hasn't had it for awhile. Even when he was the Co-MVP in 2003, he was throwing Wounded Ducks all thru the season(Most Notibly the TD pass to McCariens in the Playoff game in B-more).
After one bad game, McNair's arm is dead again :grbac: