Well, I guess the honeymoon is over on this site ~ to bad it couldn't have lasted at least til midseason. It was nice while it lasted.:(
Printable View
Well, I guess the honeymoon is over on this site ~ to bad it couldn't have lasted at least til midseason. It was nice while it lasted.:(
I still love ya' AZ.:thumbup:
The root of the problem as I see it is this.
People who defend McNair see to automatically be labeld as the "Everything is great because we are 4-0" fan.
And the people who are disappointed with his play and say it are labeled as the "We're not gonna give any credit to McNair because we spent alot of money and should be getting better results" fan.
And of course Kyle Boller gets thrown into the mix to add to the fire.
This offense MUST get better. Yes, the numbers aren't there and the play has been sloppy. But the pocket presence and poise is there with McNair. That's undeniable IMO. You can read the quotes and listen to the players. They don't panic because he doesn't. And THAT is the single most important thing that McNair has brought.
Seems to me that there is no gray area here. No constructive talk. Just alot of bickering about a player who isn't starting. Some believe that we would be in the same position with him as we are with McNair. I disagree. And again, it's not about the numbers to me.
Many here said that we wouldn't beat a quality team after the first 3 games. Well, we just did.
PP
Yea- Just a spat. I don't want to ignore anyone unless buck pops back up.
Remember- These QB wars go back to '98 when we started. The Mods here know someone threatened to drive to my house and beat me cause I thought Tony Banks sucked.
And remember- I've done my share of bitching and moaning about our offense. But I blame BB and not many people really want to do that. So I've caught my share of flak.
As for the current state of affairs- The offense has been same ole so on that we agree. Where we differ is the QB. I believe he has made us better while another group think we could be doing the same thing with the other guy. The bigger issue for me on this thread was enjoying the comeback win, and trying to quash the old vs new web site insults (and the 'go post somewhere else') type comments.
I hear what you're saying High, but as you can see things don't really ever blow over. Grudges that started at YBR have already wormed their way into the phsyce of this site. It's probably only a matter of time until this place implodes the same way YBR did. I guess the reality is that football is just to volitle a subject to ever allow for civilized discussions for any lenght of time.