Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
If Harbs is top 10, then he's at #9 or 10.
I'd put him in the 9 to 12 ranking, right about where a Tony Romo type coach should ranked.
Good enough to get a talented team to the playoffs, but can't make the crucial decisions that are needed when they're needed to help take the team further..
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Harabugh top 5? Only if Reid is considered a top 5 coach too.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ravenray
Harbuagh is a fraud. Luck into a HC job on a team with great talents on defense. Now he is going to be expose.
I think this is what needs to be considered. when he was hired the Ravens had a lot of talent on defense and that's how they won their games. Basically, for the first few years, they won in spite of him, not because of him. Now, we have a void in talent on defense, so we need good coaching to win. If we need to rely on our coaching staff to prepare the team, we are in trouble.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
I'd put Harbaugh in the middle of the pack of head coaches in the NFL. Top 5? Yeah right, top 10 is stretching it too. He makes some terrible decisions as a HC, for example keeping around Cam Cameron and getting Dean Piss hired
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
landspeed
Wow you this is hilarious
I read "we have to get rid of other" and decided with that alone that this is just completely wrong.
Michael oher is a top 5 RT.
It is not his fault that he is put in the wrong position.
That right there is harbaughs fault.
You people make these issues to be so black and white
Huh? Michael Oher should not be in the NFL.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
steelerhater
Huh? Michael Oher should not be in the NFL.
Hyperbole much?
He's not a LT or even ideal for a RT, but he would be a dominant guard.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PerpetuallyBored74
but he would be a dominant guard.
How can you make such statement when he has never played there? He isn't big enough to block DTs.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
psuasskicker
But this team has two big problems.
1) Cam. Duh. He obviously needs to go and I'm having trouble seeing a scenario that doesn't end in the Ravens in the Super Bowl where Cam comes back next year.
2) This team has a personnel deficit. Certainly the OL is awful. Oher and Birk almost have to be replaced. LG is a huge hole. Osemele needs to develop but he's not playing well right now. Yanda's the only decent OL and he may now be injured.
- C -
Harbs has stuck by Cam when he should have dumped him two years ago, so Cam and Harbs are attached IMO.
He offloads the defensive and offensive gameplans to his DC & OC, so he is a game manager type coach... Fine... but you better be a good one. Last two weeks... No balls at the end of the 1Hs to try to get a FG when they had about 1min both times with 2TOs. Horrible challenge against Pitt. And that stupid fake punt formation TO today... Come On... If you're not gonna fake it, take the fricking Delay of Game... That was flatout stupid. He is not a good manager of TOs.
Seriously, I don't really see where you have proof Harbs is a great coach on the areas he is responsible for. The players have been pretty damn good while he's here. He is an ok coach at best. And if he had the coaching acumen, he wouldnt have let it get this bad with Cam.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
steelerhater
I think this is what needs to be considered. when he was hired the Ravens had a lot of talent on defense and that's how they won their games. Basically, for the first few years, they won in spite of him, not because of him. Now, we have a void in talent on defense, so we need good coaching to win. If we need to rely on our coaching staff to prepare the team, we are in trouble.
When he was hired the Ravens were coming off a 5-11 season. But nah, he was totally a detriment.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GaTechRavens
When he was hired the Ravens were coming off a 5-11 season. But nah, he was totally a detriment.
He took over an already good team that was entirely injured the previous season.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GaTechRavens
When he was hired the Ravens were coming off a 5-11 season. But nah, he was totally a detriment.
The team was 5-11 because Bilick lost the team, hopefully it's same this year with Harbaugh.
Re: Calls to fire Harbaugh are ridiculous
Quote:
Originally Posted by
seraph
He took over an already good team that was entirely injured the previous season.
Injured...you mean like the team this year? The one that isn't going 5-11?